The most notable Free Grace advocates , often called Name_conferral `` Antinomians '' , were charismatic Anne Hutchinson , her brother-in-law Reverend John Wheelwright , and Massachusetts Bay Governor Henry Vane .

The Colony 's orthodox ministers held Hold meetings Communication with Cotton , Wheelwright , and Hutchinson in the fall of 1636 .

However , Cotton invited Request Wheelwright to speak Expressing_publicly at the Boston church during services Rite that day , and his sermon created Creating a furor which deepened Cause_change_of_position_on_a_scale the growing Expansion division .

In March 1637 , the court accused Judgment_communication Wheelwright of contempt and sedition , but he was not sentenced Legal_rulings .

During the election Change_of_leadership of May 1637 , the free grace advocates suffered Confronting_problem two major setbacks Confronting_problem when John Winthrop defeated Conquering Vane in the gubernatorial race , and the Boston magistrates were voted Choosing out of office who had supported Supporting Hutchinson and Wheelwright .

The idea that Hutchinson played Participation a central and singular role in the controversy went largely unchallenged until 2002 , when Michael Winship 's account of the controversy portrayed Publishing Cotton , Wheelwright , and Vane as equally complicit with her .